Topics
Latest
AI
Amazon
Apps
Biotech & Health
Climate
Cloud Computing
Commerce
Crypto
Enterprise
EVs
Fintech
Fundraising
Gadgets
Gaming
Government & Policy
Hardware
Layoffs
Media & Entertainment
Meta
Microsoft
Privacy
Robotics
Security
Social
Space
Startups
TikTok
Transportation
Venture
More from TechCrunch
Staff
Events
Startup Battlefield
StrictlyVC
Newsletters
Podcasts
Videos
Partner Content
TechCrunch Brand Studio
Crunchboard
Contact Us
As US weighs response to Chinese AI, industry urges against broad open-weight restrictions
Several AI companies, including Hugging Face, Meta, Microsoft, Mistral, and Nvidia, have signed an open letter urging policymakers not to impose broad “premature restrictions” on open-weight AI models. The letter comes as Washington debates how the U.S. should respond to allegations that Chinese AI labs are stealing intellectual property from their American counterparts, and growing in capability.
The letter doesn’t mention China at all, but it comes in the wake of reports that the Trump administration has been considering banning Chinese open-weight models, and potentially issuing sanctions against AI companies from the country. The White House has even accused Moonshot AI of distilling Anthropic’s Fable model to train its recently released and, by all measures, very impressive, Kimi K3 model.
The missive appears to be aimed at discouraging a total ban on Chinese models, as well as ensuring the administration’s response to alleged Chinese distillation doesn’t spill over into broader restrictions on open-weight AI or common techniques like distillation:
Policymakers should be careful not to conflate legitimate model-development techniques with misappropriation. Distillation, or the practice of using one model’s outputs to help train or improve another, is a widely used technique for model improvement, evaluation, and validation. It reflects a long tradition of learning from, building upon, and improving existing technologies, a tradition that has helped drive innovation since the rise of the open-source software movement.
By contrast, unlawful efforts to extract value from closed models raise legitimate concerns. Those concerns should be addressed through targeted legal and commercial frameworks rather than sweeping restrictions on techniques that play an important role in AI innovation.
Or as Amjad Masad, CEO of Replit (which also signed the letter), told TechCrunch: “I think banning Chinese open models is as good as banning open models in general.” He pointed out that Thinking Machines Lab’s new open model, Inkling, was trained with the help of Moonshot’s Kimi 2.5. “It’s an ecosystem, and the precedent [a ban would] set is bad.”
Thinking Machines Lab’s new open model, Inkling
The letter also pushes back on arguments in the industry that open-weight models are inherently dangerous because they expand access to powerful models, which can be used in cyberattacks or other nefarious activities, without any oversight.
open-weight models are inherently dangerous
“The right response to this risk is not to prohibit open weights. In a world where cybersecurity attackers use advanced AI, defenders need access to models with comparable capabilities so they can detect, simulate, and respond to emerging threats,” the letter reads. “Open models broaden defensive capability, increase transparency, and allow vulnerabilities to be discovered and remediated across many teams.”
Last week, OpenAI disclosed that while testing GPT-5.6 Sol and another unnamed model, one of the systems exploited a weakness in its testing environment to access a Hugging Face repository containing a solution to a coding benchmark. One could argue the model’s goal wasn’t malicious, and that it was effectively cheating on a test to get the highest score. But the incident sparked debate about the risks of concentrating advanced AI technology behind a handful of closed providers.
access a Hugging Face repository
Hugging Face said it was not able to defend itself against the attack with commercial frontier AI models because their guardrails blocked its efforts. The closed AI models it used were unable to distinguish between being asked to build exploits for an attacker and a defender trying to detect them. The company instead had to pivot to using Chinese AI firm Z.ai’s GLM 5.2, a powerful open-weight model, to defend itself against the attack.
The letter highlights a divide in the AI industry. Companies like OpenAI and Anthropic have urged the administration to respond to alleged IP theft by Chinese AI firms as open-weight models grow rapidly in capability. The outcome could have major implications on their business models, which is being threatened by the spread of cheap, highly capable, and accessible AI models.
These companies, alongside other closed source AI developers like Google DeepMind and SpaceX, are notable in their absence at the bottom of this letter.
Those who signed the letter have an obvious economic stake in seeing open AI models flourish. Companies like Nvidia, Microsoft Azure, and other infrastructure providers have a vested interest in pushing for commoditized models: If models are interchangeable, people will buy more GPUs, rent more cloud capacity, and build more applications.
The letter encourages policymakers to expand access to compute for startups and researchers; invest in shared training assets like datasets, tools, and evaluation frameworks; and “[keep] the frontier plural by avoiding premature restrictions on open models that stifle competition or drive innovation overseas.”
This article has been updated with comment from Amjad Masad, CEO of Replit.
Topics
When you purchase through links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. This doesn’t affect our editorial independence.
we may earn a small commission
Senior Reporter
Rebecca Bellan is a senior reporter at TechCrunch where she covers the business, policy, and emerging trends shaping artificial intelligence. Her work has also appeared in Forbes, Bloomberg, The Atlantic, The Daily Beast, and other publications.
You can contact or verify outreach from Rebecca by emailing rebecca.bellan@techcrunch.com or via encrypted message at rebeccabellan.491 on Signal.
Scale faster. Grow your portfolio. Gain practical expertise. No matter your goal, Disrupt can empower you.Save up to $330 today!
Most Popular
OpenAI says Hugging Face was breached by its pre-release models
Russell Brandom
OpenAI says Hugging Face was breached by its pre-release models
OpenAI says Hugging Face was breached by its pre-release models
OpenAI says Hugging Face was breached by its pre-release models
Russell Brandom
Jack Dorsey is taking on Slack with Buzz, a group chat platform for teams and their AI agents
Amanda Silberling
Jack Dorsey is taking on Slack with Buzz, a group chat platform for teams and their AI agents
Jack Dorsey is taking on Slack with Buzz, a group chat platform for teams and their AI agents
Jack Dorsey is taking on Slack with Buzz, a group chat platform for teams and their AI agents
Amanda Silberling
Light made a flip phone — it’s colorful and it’s cheap
Amanda Silberling
Light made a flip phone — it’s colorful and it’s cheap
Light made a flip phone — it’s colorful and it’s cheap
Light made a flip phone — it’s colorful and it’s cheap
Amanda Silberling
AI music generator Suno breach affects 55M users, per Have I Been Pwned
Zack Whittaker
AI music generator Suno breach affects 55M users, per Have I Been Pwned
AI music generator Suno breach affects 55M users, per Have I Been Pwned
AI music generator Suno breach affects 55M users, per Have I Been Pwned
Zack Whittaker
Anthropic’s landmark $1.5B copyright settlement is approved
Kirsten Korosec
Anthropic’s landmark $1.5B copyright settlement is approved
Anthropic’s landmark $1.5B copyright settlement is approved
Anthropic’s landmark $1.5B copyright settlement is approved
Kirsten Korosec
Google is working on a new AI chip designed to make Gemini more efficient
Lucas Ropek
Google is working on a new AI chip designed to make Gemini more efficient
Google is working on a new AI chip designed to make Gemini more efficient
Google is working on a new AI chip designed to make Gemini more efficient
Lucas Ropek
Judge pauses $110B Paramount-Warner Bros. merger
Aisha Malik
Judge pauses $110B Paramount-Warner Bros. merger
Judge pauses $110B Paramount-Warner Bros. merger
Judge pauses $110B Paramount-Warner Bros. merger
Aisha Malik